Sheriff in Nancy Guthrie case says no glove found at home, defends ongoing work with FBI

He added: "We don't hold information from anybody that's going to help us. Why would we do that? There are no egos here. This is all about finding Nancy."

Nanos said he contacted the FBI the next working day after Guthrie went missing and said that federal agents are embedded with his team.

"They sit right next to the FBI. Come to my office, and I'll show you - they're sitting right there with my team," he said. "They are there every minute of the day, and they want to find her."

On the handling of evidence, Nanos defended his department's decision to use a long-standing private lab rather than splitting evidence between facilities, including the FBI's crime lab in Quantico, Virginia.

He said the Guthrie family DNA markers and other swabs were already sent to that lab early in the investigation, making it more efficient to continue using the same facility.

"They're both great labs. They both have great equipment and smart people. We trust the FBI's crime lab. We've used them before. But in this case, we just started with this lab," he said. "It's just that simple."

Regarding ransom notes, Nanos said the FBI is taking the lead.

"All the ransom stuff we've given to the FBI - they're the experts on that," he said. "It would be very inappropriate for me to comment on something that I told them to do."

"You always consider all possibilities," he said. "But yeah, the obvious is what? It is an obvious kidnapping."

When asked whether anyone has been ruled out, Nanos said investigators may deprioritize individuals but remain open to revisiting leads.

"Nobody's really ever eliminated," he said.

The sheriff also rejected criticism that investigators released the crime scene too soon.

"We remove the evidence, we swab evidence, we take evidence, and we go," he told Finn. "We got all the evidence that was there to gather."

Cleaning blood from a scene, he added, "is not what we do."

Nanos said deputy vehicles currently stationed outside the home are there at the family's request for security.

Those cars "are there because the family said they can't - they don't want to be at the house and they've asked, can we provide security, so nobody breaks into the home," he said.

Jan. 31, 2026

Feb. 1, 2026