Monday, 17 Mar 2025

Maher asks 'why do we want to bring back manufacturing' as Trump makes jobs argument in tariff war

HBO's Bill Maher took President Trump to task over his goal to bring back manufacturing to the US as a result of his trade war, arguing it's "so 70s" and that such jobs are obsolete.


Maher asks 'why do we want to bring back manufacturing' as Trump makes jobs argument in tariff war
1.7 k views

"I have one basic question: Why do we want to bring back manufacturing?" Maher asked his panel on Friday. "It's so 70s, you know? I mean, that ship has sailed. You know, there are countries that make jeans for $11. We're never going to be that country again." 

"China's moving into the AI age, and he wants to go back to manufacturing, which, by the way, if you create new jobs, who's gonna take them? Robots," Maher continued. "That's who's gonna take them anyway! He acts like progress itself is woke. And nobody spoke more against woke bulls--- than me, but progress itself is not woke. We've moved into a different era."

"In the 70s, the largest share of our GDP was in the middle class. And that was not separate from the fact that 25% of our economy was in manufacturing," Ungar-Sargon said. "Now, the top 20% controls over 50% of the GDP. Our economy was an upward funnel of wealth, and the largest share, which used to be in manufacturing, which gave a lot of working class people a middle class standard of living, now the largest share is in real estate and finance, meaning that asset-rich Americans are controlling over 50% of the GDP, and they have left the working class out of all of that prosperity that was generated." 

"Manufacturing is still being done. It's just being done in other countries," she stressed. 

"For wages we will not work for," Maher interjected. 

"That's exactly right, Bill," Ungar-Sargon responded. "That's what the tariffs are for. They are to make American workers more competitive in the global market. Why are we accepting that there should be a race to the bottom? You know, China, what is its competitive advantage over us? It's that it pays slave wages. Why should we accept that? They're still manufacturing our PPE, our pharmaceuticals, our cars. They're making all that stuff." 

After echoing Trump's argument that the outsourcing of key goods is a "national security" issue for the US, Ungar-Sargon told Maher it's "really important that we have a stake in the manufacturing of the things that we need as a nation, so that when China decides that it wants to go to war against us, we're not relying on them for steel and aluminum in order to fight them."

"Ok, at least that's an answer," Maher responded. "And you think that's the way it's gonna come out? We're gonna go through this 'transition period-'"

"Who's so upset right now? The stock market, right? It's rich people," Ungar-Sargon said. 

"This is class warfare on behalf of the working class by our president," Ungar-Sargon added. 

Fox News Digital reached out to the White House for comment. 

you may also like

Veteran-led dig of Revolutionary War battlefield seeks to shed light on history, empower disabled vets
  • by foxnews
  • descember 09, 2016
Veteran-led dig of Revolutionary War battlefield seeks to shed light on history, empower disabled vets

The founder of American Veterans Archaeological Recovery spoke with Fox News Digital about a recent veteran-led excavation at Camden Battlefield in South Carolina.

read more