Architects advocate for removal of stringent Victorian planning controls

More than 150 built-environment professionals have signed an open letter to Sonya Kilkenny, Victorian minister for planning and the suburbs, advocating for the removal of upper-level setback requirements within the state's planning scheme.

The letter, dated 2 September 2024, follows a recent announcement from the Department of Planning and Transport outlining draft controls for ten slated activity centres across Melbourne. Drafted by YIMBY Melbourne, the letter builds upon the company's research into relevant global and local precedents of high-rise residential development. It argues that building upward and without setbacks is conducive to better outcomes - both more affordable and environmentally sustainable.

"Upper-level setbacks are the most poorly-evidenced rule in the Victorian planning system, and are almost entirely indefensible. The rules are underpinned by confected terms such as 'visual bulk' and 'break up the form,' which don't mean anything and provide no material benefit to anyone," commented YIMBY Melbourne lead organiser Jonathan O'Brien. "No one goes to Paris or Prague and complains of the visual bulk. We shouldn't complain about it here in Melbourne, either."

An excerpt from the open letter reads:

Signatories to the open letter include representatives from: Apparte, Austin Maynard Architects, Breathe, Cox Architecture, Cera Stribley, Chloe Antonio Architecture, Clarke Hopkins Clarke, Co-lab Architecture, Cumulus Studio, Edition Office, Forum, Ha Architecture, Hassell, Ian Moore Architects, Jackson Clements Burrows, Karen Abernethy Architects, Keep Studio, Kennedy Nolan, Kerry Kounnapis Architecture Practice, Kerstin Thompson Architects, Milieu Property, Murray Barker, Nightingale Housing, Schored Projects, Studio Edwards, Tecture, YIMBY, YSG and Ys Housing.

The complete letter can be viewed online.